Top 4 Mechanical and Membrane Keyboards for Gamers: Which One Should You Buy?
When it comes to gaming, having the right keyboard can make a significant difference in your performance and overall experience. Whether you're a casual gamer or a competitive player, the choice between mechanical and membrane keyboards can be daunting. Mechanical keyboards are often favored for their tactile feedback and durability, while membrane keyboards are usually quieter and more affordable. Understanding the strengths and weaknesses of each type can help you make an informed decision tailored to your gaming style.
In this post, we’ll explore four standout keyboards that cater to gamers: two mechanical options and two membrane choices. Each keyboard offers unique features, pros, and cons, which we will discuss in detail. By the end, you’ll have a clearer understanding of what to look for in a gaming keyboard and which one might be the best fit for you.
Products Featured in This Article
Redragon K552 Mechanical Gaming Keyboard RGB LED Backlit Wired with Anti-Dust Proof Switches for Windows PC (White, 87 Key Red Switches)
👥 What customers said: Customers generally appreciate the build quality, customizable RGB lighting, and satisfying typing experience of the keyboard. However, there are concerns regarding durability and customer service responsiveness.
- "Typing on it is so comfortable and feels like pillows on your fingers."
- "This is the best keyboard you can get for the price."
- "It has a lot of animations you can choose from."
- Use FN + ` to customize individual key lighting.
- Consider adding O-rings to dampen noise.
- Check the manual for RGB settings; they may not be intuitive.
- Solid build quality with a satisfying clicky feel.
- Bright and customizable RGB lighting options.
- Affordable price point for a mechanical keyboard.
- Some users experienced key malfunctions after a few months.
- Customer service response times can be slow.
- No dedicated software for RGB customization; relies on keybinds.
Razer BlackWidow Chroma: Clicky RGB Mechanical Gaming Keyboard - 5 Macro Keys - Razer Green Mechanical Switches (Tactile and Clicky)
👥 What customers said: The Razer BlackWidow Chroma keyboard has received mixed reviews, with many praising its build quality and RGB features, while others express dissatisfaction with durability and software issues.
- "Typing is so responsive and has great sounding clicks."
- "The colors are super bright and can be customized."
- "Razer's dedication to the gaming community is commendable."
- Customize lighting and macros through Razer Synapse for best results.
- Ensure you have high-power USB ports for connectivity.
- Regularly clean the keyboard to maintain performance and appearance.
- Sturdy build quality and premium feel.
- Highly customizable RGB lighting with vivid effects.
- Satisfying mechanical switches that enhance typing experience.
- Durability issues with key switches and LED lighting.
- Complicated software requiring constant internet connection.
- Some keys have inconsistent lighting and responsiveness.
Logitech G710+ Mechanical Gaming Keyboard with Tactile High-Speed Keys - Black
👥 What customers said: The Logitech G710+ mechanical keyboard has received mixed reviews from customers, with many praising its features and build quality, while others report issues with key durability and lighting. Users appreciate the keyboard's tactile response and programmable keys, but some have experienced problems with key lighting and breakage. Overall, it appears to be a solid choice for gamers and typists, albeit with some caveats.
- "The backlit is beautiful, and the mechanical keys feel amazing."
- "It's the best mechanical keyboard I have ever used."
- "The keyboard works amazingly in both the typing department and the gaming department."
- Consider removing O-rings if they affect key feel for you.
- Test different Cherry MX switches before purchasing to find your preference.
- Use Logitech software for programming macro keys effectively.
- Tactile Cherry MX Brown switches provide great feedback for typing and gaming.
- Programmable macro keys enhance functionality for various applications.
- Sturdy construction with a pleasing aesthetic design.
- Key lighting issues reported, including uneven illumination and flickering.
- Fragile keycaps can break easily, leading to replacement concerns.
- Wrist rest feels cheap and does not match keyboard quality.
Buyer’s Guide
- Key Features: Focus on build quality, warranty, and ease of use.
- Price vs. Value: Don’t overpay for minor upgrades; compare core specs.
- Real-World Fit: Check size/weight, comfort, and noise in everyday use.
FAQ
1. What is the difference between mechanical and membrane keyboards?
Mechanical keyboards use individual switches for each key, offering better tactile feedback and longevity, while membrane keyboards use a pressure pad system that is quieter and usually less expensive.
2. Are mechanical keyboards better for gaming?
Generally, yes. Mechanical keyboards provide faster response times, better durability, and a more satisfying typing experience, making them a popular choice among gamers.
3. How important is customizable RGB lighting?
It depends on personal preference. Customizable RGB lighting can enhance the gaming experience and aesthetics, but it is not essential for performance.
4. What should I look for in a gaming keyboard?
Consider the key switch type, build quality, customization options, and any additional features like programmable keys or wrist rests that may enhance your comfort while gaming.
5. Do I need software to customize my keyboard?
Some keyboards require specific software for customization, while others allow you to set up features directly on the keyboard without additional software.
In evaluating these keyboards, it’s clear that each has its strengths and weaknesses. The Redragon K552 offers an affordable entry into mechanical keyboards with customizable RGB lighting, but some users have reported durability issues. The Razer BlackWidow Chroma stands out for its premium feel and vivid RGB features, yet it may come with software complications. The Logitech G710+ is praised for its tactile feedback and programmable keys, but users have noted concerns about key durability and lighting inconsistencies.
Ultimately, the best keyboard for you will depend on your gaming style, budget, and personal preferences. Whether you lean towards the tactile responsiveness of mechanical switches or the quieter operation of membrane keyboards, it’s crucial to choose a keyboard that enhances your gameplay rather than detracts from it.
Explore the options discussed here, and consider your gaming needs before making a decision. With the right keyboard, you can elevate your gaming experience and enjoy every moment spent in front of your screen.
Conclusion
If you need a quick recommendation: pick the “Best Overall” for balance, “Best Budget” for price, and “Best Premium” for top performance.